Withdrawal method (drawdown rate)
How the engine sizes your annual drawdown once you stop working.
Partially live. Some option values for this strategy are captured by ProjectFi but not yet consumed by the engine. The Intent-only chip in the dashboard reflects the same gap.
What it models
- •
Draw only what you spend (default): each year the engine draws exactly your retirement target (inflated for CPI). Your portfolio grows if markets outrun your spending.
- •
4% fixed real: the engine draws the maximum of (your inflated retirement target, 4% of the starting retirement balance inflated for CPI) each year. The 4% acts as a floor, so if your real expenses exceed it the engine still pulls expenses.
- •
Percentage of current balance: draw a fixed percentage of the balance at the start of each retirement year. Spending flexes with the portfolio. Currently captured as intent only. Engine treats as 'expenses_only' until this branch is wired.
When someone might apply it
- •
Some users prefer expenses-only because their lifestyle is stable and they want the portfolio to compound when markets are kind.
- •
Some users prefer 4% fixed real because the conservative withdrawal floor has decades of historical data backing it (Trinity Study, etc.).
- •
Some users prefer percentage-of-balance because they want spending to flex with their portfolio. Bigger years in good markets, restrained years in bad ones.
Trade-offs
- •
Expenses-only doesn't adapt to market conditions: a sequence of bad years still pulls the same dollar amount, accelerating depletion.
- •
4% fixed real maintains a floor under spending. In years when your actual expenses are below 4%, the engine spends up to the floor anyway, which can leave you over-drawing in markets where the floor is unwarranted.
- •
Percentage-of-balance removes sequence-of-returns risk but means lifestyle drops in bad markets, which can be psychologically harder to live with than the other two.
Note: The 'percentage of current balance' option captures intent but is not wired to the engine yet. The engine treats it as 'expenses_only' for now.
ProjectFi is a planning tool, not financial advice. Projections are estimates only. Please consult a licensed financial adviser before making investment decisions.